Thick and chewy brown butter toffee cookies are made with my favorite chocolate chip cookie dough amended with bread flour and cornstarch for maximum chewiness. We're adding homemade toffee pieces, which are easy to make and so much better than storebought, and pairing them with big chunks of dark chocolate. The secret? Layering salt three times to balance out the sweetness.
In a large bowl, add sugars and molasses. Set to the side.
1 cup light brown sugar, 1/3 cup granulated sugar, 1 tsp molasses
In a separate container, whisk together your dry ingredients. Measure out the chocolate chunks and toffee pieces and set to the side.
2 cups bread flour, 2 tbsp cornstarch, 1/2 tsp baking soda, 1 tsp kosher salt, 3/4 cup toffee pieces, 1 cup dark chocolate chunks
In a medium saucepan, place two sticks (one cup) of salted butter and heat over medium low on your stovetop. As the butter melts, add the dry milk powder, if using.
3/4 cup melted browned butter, 2 tbsp dry milk powder
While browning, the butter should be stirred often. The milk powder will make it look much thicker and creamier, but keep going until it is golden brown with that toasty, nutty aroma.
Once the browned butter is ready, pour it into your measuring cup or use a kitchen scale to make sure you have the right amount. Let it cool for about 5-20 minutes or until just slightly warm.To speed it up, please the measuring cup in a bowl of cold water and stir often.
Pour the butter into the bowl with the sugars and molasses. Stir in until incorporated as well as you can. Then, add your vanilla extract and the room temperature eggs. Whisk until creamy and noticeably lighter than before.
1 large egg, 1 egg yolk, 1/2 tbsp vanilla extract
Then, add the dry ingredients - the bread flour, cornstarch, baking soda, salt, the chocolate chunks, and the toffee pieces - and mix in until combined. I often use my hands to help mix everything together. You don't want any dry sections of flour.*If the dough seems dry at this time, add a small amount of extra melted brown butter until it comes together. This can happen if you use a measuring cup instead of measuring by weight. You can also add a small splash of milk or cream. There are images of what the dough should look like when properly combined in my blog post.
Scoop or weigh out the dough. I like to use a 4 oz scoop and shape it into a conical tower to help the cookies bake up extra thick. Sprinkle with flaky sea salt and add a couple extra toffee pieces on top of each dough ball.
1/4 cup extra toffee pieces, 1 tsp flaky sea salt
Refrigerate for about 2 hours or until the dough is firm. (You can also store the dough for a few days. Just transfer to an airtight container. The flavors will improve the longer the dough rests.)
When ready to bake, prep your baking sheets with parchment paper and preheat the oven to 375F. When baking big cookies, you can usually bake about 6 on a half sheet pan at a time. Be sure to space them well.
Bake for 11-12 minutes in a fully preheated oven. The cookies may still look slightly soft or a little wet at this point, but they will finish cooking on the hot pan.Remove from the oven. The toffee will melt in the oven and likely ooze out of your cookies. To fix this, use a metal cake ring or even a wide mouth canning lid band to reshape the cookies while they are still hot (just gently swirl the cookie in the cake ring). Allow the cookies to firm up all the way on the baking sheets before removing. Serve warm or store in an airtight container for 2-3 days.
Notes
You can replace the bread flour with all purpose flour.
Please be sure to measure your flour carefully or your cookies may turn out unintentionally dry. When possible, it's best to weigh out your ingredients using a kitchen scale.You do not need to add the molasses, if you don't want to. It's basically a cheat for making dark brown sugar without making a trip to the store. I have made these cookies without molasses and just using light brown sugar many times. The extra depth of flavor from the molasses is just really nice.I use a Brod & Taylor dough whisk for this recipe every time and it has just the right spacing to help me stir everything evenly by hand without the dough getting stuck in the whisk itself. My favorite kitchen tool!